Green Clean: How “Environmental” is Remediation?

Written By Keith Gaskill, L.P.G., EnviroForensics, in collaboration with Stephen R. Henshaw, P.G., President & CEO, EnviroForensics.
As seen in the March 2012 issue of Cleaner & Launderer.

PDF Version

Environmental impact due to historical drycleaning practices is not a rarity.  In fact, it’s common to find drycleaning solvents in the soil, groundwater and vapor under and around current and former drycleaning facilities.  A big part of our job is to figure out the means to best remediate the environmental impact.

The purpose of remediation is to abate the environmental impact, clean up the contamination and protect human health and the environment.  But just how much are we affecting our overall environment by cleaning your site?  Does removing 50 tons of impacted soil from under a drycleaning facility clean a site?  Where does that soil go?  Does the installation of a mechanical remediation system such as Soil Vapor Extraction (SVE) not have its own environmental impacts?  The systems run on electricity and electricity must be produced, many times by the combustion of coal or hydrocarbons which creates greenhouse gas emissions and sulfur and other non-friendly emissions.  Even the protective Tyvek suits, Latex gloves and disposable sampling equipment creates waste which is landfilled.  On one hand we are cleaning up a problem and on the other we are creating a problem. Continue reading “Green Clean: How “Environmental” is Remediation?”

Fate of Spilled Perc in the Subsurface: Understanding the Basics When it Gets in the Ground

FIND OUT WHAT MAKES PERC SUCH A COMPLICATED CONTAMINANT TO ADDRESS 

Releases of Perchloroethylene (PCE) to the subsurface from drycleaning operations and related PCE handling are not rare. The result of environmental investigation in response to a confirmed spill is not only to determine the concentration of materials in the ground, but to develop a conceptual site model as to where the contaminant is going. Once a model of what’s there, where it’s going, and how it’s getting there has been constructed, a remedy can be selected and implemented. 

Read 7 common questions about PCE spills

HOW PERC GETS INTO THE GROUND
The releases at the surface consist of primarily two types. Free phase PCE in dense non-aqueous phase liquid (DNAPL) pure form and dissolved phase PCE in water. Current accidental releases are often spills resulting from the drycleaning process. Historically, chemical handling practices were not as refined as they are today and there may have been releases related to cleaning of filters; distiller boil-overs; storage equipment failures, or disposal of hazardous process waste as well as spills from older drycleaning machines and operations. The PCE may be introduced to the subsurface on dirt or gravel, which allows an easy pathway to the soil, or will travel directly, though untreated concrete (and can even dissolve asphalt). 

The PCE in the pure or dissolved phase will adsorb to soil particles as it migrates downward (gravity flow). These adsorbed molecules of PCE are then quantified later by selecting soil samples during soil coring activities. In some cases, the geology at a site will be such that the released materials will have a preferential pathway along a seam of sand or even a utility corridor. The spilled PCE will then appear to have spread out.

As frequently observed, the PCE will migrate deep enough to where groundwater is encountered and a groundwater contamination plume is initiated. Should geological conditions allow, a migrating DNAPL plume will continue to “dive” into the saturated subsurface to a point where it will pool on an impermeable or less permeable geologic unit and continue to dissolve into the groundwater. 

INVESTIGATING A PERC CONTAMINATION
A basic investigation into groundwater flow determines two important characteristics: direction and velocity. A dissolved phase PCE plume will travel in the direction of groundwater flow. Groundwater, more than any other mechanism, is the likely culprit for PCE leaving a drycleaner spill site and onto a neighboring property. Through aquifer investigation, flow characteristics can be determined and the flow of a contaminant plume can be better understood and perhaps predicted.

The fate and transport of the dissolved phase PCE plume in groundwater is also affected by other non-destructive and destructive processes. Some of these non-destructive processes include absorption onto organic matter; dilution of PCE concentration by recharge of cleaner groundwater from upgradient and surface percolation of rainwater; and volatilization of the PCE from the groundwater plume. One of the most important destructive processes working on PCE plumes is called reductive dechlorination which includes naturally occurring subsurface microbes available in saturated units, a process occurs to DNAPL, adsorbed phase, and dissolved phase PCE. The dechlorination or degradation process produces daughter products as it works toward non-regulated non-toxic compounds. 

The primary daughter products include trichloroethylene (TCE), cis-1,2-dichloroethylene (cis-DCE), trans-1,2-dichloroethylene (trans-DCE), and vinyl chloride (VC). The daughter products can be as dangerous to human health and the environment as PCE (in some cases, more dangerous). During the investigation, these daughter products are commonly detected in the groundwater samples and provide information on the naturally occurring chemistry at a site. 

Learn how PERC daughter products help an environmental consultant pinpoint when a PERC release occurred

PCE and its daughter products are volatile in nature and will volatilize into vapor phase impacts. The vapor phase impact will be present in the soil and can enter basements, crawl spaces, and the breathing space in surface structures. Contaminants may also follow preferential pathways such as underground utility corridors speeding up the migration of the contaminants where present. Vapor intrusion investigations have become increasingly more prevalent in recent years and are needed to prevent risk of solvent exposure to inhabitants in adjacent buildings and residences. 

NEXT STEPS IN ADDRESSING A PERC CONTAMINATION
The multiphase transport nature of PCE and daughter products in the subsurface creates a significant challenge to characterize. It is important to keep up with the most recent advances in investigation technology and interpretation techniques so that a successful and cost-effective remediation methodology can be employed on a site-specific basis.

Learn more about our environmental investigation and remediation services.

Getting Help With Cleanup Costs

National Clothesline, October 2003

Steve Henshaw, President and CEO of EnviroForensics and Policy Find

The bad news knocked Denver Cain for the proverbial loop. He only wanted to sell his drycleaning business in Indianapolis — The Washboard Laundry and Drycleaning — and retire in peace.  Instead, he was surprised to discover that his property was contaminated with perc. Cain’s financial future looked dismal at best. The property’s value was estimated to be worth $300,000, but cleanup costs were projected to be between $500,000 and $750,000.  “I spent quite a bit of money with a law firm,” Cain recalled. “I was getting nowhere.” Continue reading “Getting Help With Cleanup Costs”

EnviroForensics Uncovers Liability in Site Cleanups

CONTAMINATED DRYCLEANING PROPERTIES KEEP FIRM BUSY

BY: SCOTT OLSON, INDIANAPOLIS BUSINESS JOURNAL

As Seen in the July 14-20, 2003, Vol. 24, No. 18,  issue of the Indianapolis Business Journal.

PDF Version

Dry cleaner Denver Cain provided a blunt assessment about the pickle he’d be in if he were left to finance a half-million-dollar cleanup at one of his properties.

“I’d be in deep doo-doo,” he said.

Fortunately for Cain, he found the consulting firm Environmental Forensic Investigations Inc. The locally based company, known as EnviroForensics, specializes in locating sources to pay for site investigations and cleanups. Continue reading “EnviroForensics Uncovers Liability in Site Cleanups”